Renting is not throwing money away, and buying is not automatically an investment. Both have costs that do not come back: rent on one side; interest, property tax, insurance, upkeep and the cost of buying and selling on the other. This calculator adds those costs up year by year, gives each side credit for what it gets back, and shows which one is cheaper for the time you expect to stay.
The default example
A $400,000 home with $80,000 down, a 30-year mortgage at 6.5%, property tax of 1.1% of the value, $2,000 a year of insurance, maintenance of 1% of the value, 3% closing costs to buy and 6% to sell, and 3% yearly price growth. The alternative is renting for $2,200 a month, rising 3% a year, with spare money invested at 5%.
| After 10 years | Buy | Rent |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost in year 1 | $2,889.28 | $2,200.00 |
| Paid over 10 years | $451,010.71 | $302,646.41 |
| Cash from selling the home | −$234,028.96 | $0.00 |
| Investment earnings | $0.00 | −$77,132.54 |
| Net cost over 10 years | $216,981.75 | $225,513.87 |
The buyer puts $92,000 down up front and has a $320,000 mortgage with a principal and interest payment of $2,022.62. After 10 years the home is worth $537,566.55 and the loan balance is $271,283.60. Buying comes out $8,532.12 ahead, and the “See the net cost year by year” table shows it catching up with renting in year 9.
How the comparison works
The two households spend the same amount each month: whichever costs more, owning or renting. The buyer pays the up-front costs; the renter invests that same amount instead. In any month where one side’s costs are lower, that side invests the difference. Here owning costs more, so the renter invests $689.28 a month at first, and the gap changes each year as rent and home costs rise.
At the end of each year the calculator imagines a sale. The buyer gets the home’s value minus the loan balance and the selling costs. Net cost is everything paid, minus that sale, minus investment earnings. Comparing net costs is the same as comparing how much wealth each household has at the end.
Time is the biggest factor
Buying has large one-time costs: closing costs going in and commissions going out. Early mortgage payments are mostly interest, so equity builds slowly at first. That is why short stays favor renting:
| Years | Cheaper option | By |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | Renting | $21,850.76 |
| 10 | Buying | $8,532.12 |
| 20 | Buying | $148,231.27 |
The assumptions that move the result most
- Home price growth. At 1% a year instead of 3%, renting is $71,630.96 cheaper after 10 years.
- Investment return. At 7% instead of 5%, renting is $32,086.06 cheaper after 10 years.
- Rent. At $2,600 instead of $2,200, buying is $78,480.47 cheaper after 10 years and breaks even in year 5.
- Selling costs. Commissions are negotiable; lower selling costs help buying at every horizon.
Try a cautious and an optimistic version of each before deciding.
What is not included
Taxes are left out. Most households now take the standard deduction, so mortgage interest and property tax often give no extra tax benefit, and gains on selling your main home are often excluded up to $250,000, or $500,000 for married couples, as IRS Publication 523 explains. Investment earnings may be taxed, which favors buying a little. PMI, renters insurance, moving costs, furniture and big repairs beyond the maintenance rate are also left out.
Buying also has costs that are not money, such as less flexibility to move, and benefits that are not money, such as stability and freedom to renovate. The CFPB’s home buying resources can help you think through readiness beyond the numbers.